Roofing Material Comparison

Compare different roofing materials side-by-side to make the best choice for your home and budget

Select Materials to Compare

Select up to 4 materials to compare (currently selected: 2)

Asphalt Shingles

95% popular

The most popular roofing choice in America, offering reliability and affordability.

$3-$7/sq ft15-30 years

Metal Roofing

25% popular

Premium roofing solution offering unmatched durability and energy efficiency.

$8-$16/sq ft40-70 years

Synthetic Materials

15% popular

Modern engineered materials combining aesthetics with performance and affordability.

$7-$14/sq ft30-50 years

Clay Tile

8% popular

Traditional clay tiles offering timeless beauty and exceptional longevity.

$10-$20/sq ft50-100 years

Wood Shingles

5% popular

Natural wood shingles providing rustic charm and environmental sustainability.

$6-$12/sq ft20-40 years

Natural Slate

2% popular

The ultimate premium roofing material with unparalleled longevity and natural beauty.

$15-$30/sq ft75-150 years

Material Comparison Results

Comparing 2 materials

Asphalt Shingles

The most popular roofing choice in America, offering reliability and affordability.

Price Range:

$3-$7/sq ft

Lifespan:15-30 years

Warranty:20-30 years

Popularity:95% of homes

Durability:6/10

Energy Efficiency:5/10

Maintenance:7/10

Metal Roofing

Premium roofing solution offering unmatched durability and energy efficiency.

Price Range:

$8-$16/sq ft

Lifespan:40-70 years

Warranty:30-50 years

Popularity:25% of homes

Durability:9/10

Energy Efficiency:9/10

Maintenance:9/10

Ready to Choose Your Roofing Material?

Our roofing experts can help you select the perfect material for your home, budget, and Northeast Ohio climate.

Storm Damage? Emergency Tarping Available 24/7

2-Hour Response Time